Seafood Restaurants to Visit on Anna Maria Island – Mainsail Vacation Rentals

Seafood Restaurants to Visit on Anna Maria Island

With its close proximity right on the Gulf, you can find delicious and fresh seafood just about anywhere on Anna Maria Island.

Of course, there are some seafood restaurants on Anna Maria Island that are known for having exceptional dishes. You don’t want to miss out on visiting a couple of these top seafood picks during your trip.

Seafood dish at the Waterline Marina Resort & Beach Club’s signature restaurant in Anna Maria Island

Eliza Ann's Coastal Kitchen

Waterline Marina Resort & Beach Club’s signature restaurant offers a menu inspired by coastal locales, bridging the heritage of the land and sea. Executive Chef James Baselici runs the ship, expertly applying his extensive culinary skills and drawing inspiration from his passion for the destination. The casual marina-side restaurant with an open kitchen features rustic elements and nautical influences throughout. Enjoy handcrafted cocktails, wood-grilled oysters, blue crab hushpuppies, daily specials based on local catch, and simple vegetable preparations.

Eliza Ann’s features a solid fuel grill burning live oak to give filet mignon, fresh seafood, and other dishes a smoky, natural wood flavor. All menu selections have been crafted to form a connection with similar coastal locations, including the Carolina Lowcountry, the bayous of Louisiana and the docks of Cortez. Arrive by land or sea for daily breakfast, lunch, and dinner, nightly happy hour or weekend brunch!

Beach House Restaurant

Aesthetically, the Beach House Restaurant is one of the top Anna Maria Island attractions. This waterfront spot is one restaurant in the area that will make you feel like you’re essentially dining on the sands of the beautiful Anna Maria Island beaches. The outdoor deck gives you a beautiful view of the serene water and you can even catch a glimpse of the famous sunset the area is known for.

But the ambiance is just part of the experience at the Beach House Restaurant. Look at the menu and you’ll find phenomenal premium seafood choices to share and huge main dishes for you to keep all to yourself. Choose from shrimp plates to gumbo, salmon, or skillets of your choice, everything here is fresh. It will be an amazing experience your taste buds won’t soon forget.

Rod & Reel Pier

The famous Rod & Reel Pier restaurant is right on the water and brings you a truly Old Florida experience. A perfect pick for breakfast, lunch, or dinner, you’ll have a great meal no matter what time of day you come to this spot. The menu boasts plenty of seafood for its main courses of mahi and grouper, as well as traditional appetizers of crab cake and shrimp skewers. There’s also a kid’s menu to make this dining experience one of the many family-friendly activities on Anna Maria Island.

Blue Marlin Grill

Located on historic Bridge Street, this spot has a dedication to serving only the freshest local seafood they can get their hands on. You can have some of this delicious seafood in many different ways at this restaurant. Choose from starters, soups, salads, sandwiches, entrees and more all spotlighting the fresh catch of the day. We particularly love the Tater Soup, splashed with crumbled bacon, as well as linguini white Clam pasta.

In addition to the amazing food you can taste at the Blue Marlin Grill, you can also enjoy live music and an intimate patio. A top pick in the Anna Maria Island dining scene. You can make a reservation online, call ahead, or just drop in for any meal.

Anna Maria Oyster Bar on the Pier

If you love a good raw bar, it’s hard to top this location. There are so many seafood styled appetizers to choose from, and of course a fantastic selection of raw or steamed oysters for you to enjoy. Trying out some oysters is just one of the many things to do on Anna Maria Island that will make you feel like a true local.

If oysters aren’t your thing, don’t worry, there are plenty of other seafood dishes to choose from on the menu. You’ll find shrimp, scallops, crab, fresh filets, and more.

Seafood dish at The Sandbar Restaurant on the beach in Anna Maria Island

Sandbar Restaurant

This is another wonderful location to head to if you love dining with your toes right in the sand. Because of how close this spot is to the water, it’s hard to not have an amazing fresh caught meal, including calamari, sautéed lump crabcakes, and shrimp. Vegans can even find a few wonderful options, like the crispy Brussels sprouts.

The Sandbar puts a big focus on bringing you authentic, Old Florida dishes. It’s a great pick for any time of day and serves up an amazing brunch. The chefs also put an emphasis on ecologically responsible ingredients. Enjoy many options including ceviche, scallops, and plenty of entrees for meat eaters too.

More information

If you’re looking for other seafood options during your stay on Anna Maria Island or if your mouth is watering and you’re ready to book your vacation, contact us right away. Looking for a property management company to take the stress out of booking your rental? We can help! Start by filling our Rental Income Analysis Form, and we’ll reach out to you!

Don’t let the next amazing vacation getaway escape you. Plan ahead and have a lovely seafood-filled time on Anna Maria Island!

CONTACT US

Mainsail Vacation Rentals
5325 Marina Drive,
Holmes Beach, FL 34217
941-600-2340

PROUD PARTNER

CONNECT

Sign up for our newsletter for access to our latest specials and updates.
HAVE A QUESTION?